STF anula vínculo empregatício de motoristas com aplicativos

Supremo Tribunal Federal derrubou decisão da Justiça do Trabalho que reconhecia vínculo de emprego

A Primeira Turma do Supremo Tribunal Federal (STF) decidiu nesta terça-feira (5) que não há vínculo de emprego entre motoristas de aplicativo e as empresas que operam as plataformas. O entendimento vale para todas as plataformas.

O colegiado julgou uma decisão da Justiça do Trabalho de Minas Gerais que reconheceu vínculo de emprego entre um motorista e a plataforma Cabify.

Em seu voto, o relator do processo, ministro Alexandre de Moraes, afirmou que a Justiça Trabalhista tem descumprido reiteradamente precedentes do plenário do Supremo sobre a inexistência de relação de emprego entre as empresas de aplicativos e os motoristas.

Para o ministro, a Constituição admite outras relações de trabalho. “Aquele que faz parte da Cabify, da Uber, do iFood, ele tem a liberdade de aceitar as corridas que quer. Ele tem a liberdade de fazer o seu horário e tem a liberdade de ter outros vínculos”, justificou.

O voto de Moraes foi seguido pelos ministros Cristiano Zanin, Luiz Fux e Cármen Lucia.

Apesar de não reconhecer o vínculo de emprego, Cármen Lúcia demonstrou preocupação com o futuro dos trabalhadores e a falta de regulamentação de direitos. “Nos preocupamos com esse modelo, o que não significa adotar o modelo da legislação trabalhista como se fosse uma forma de resolver. Não tenho dúvida de que, em 20 anos ou menos, teremos um gravíssimo problema social e previdenciário. As pessoas que ficam nesse sistema de ‘uberização’ não têm os direitos sociais garantidos na Constituição por ausência de serem suportados por uma legislação”, afirmou. 

Durante o julgamento, o advogado Márcio Eurico Vitral Amaro, representante da Cabify, alegou que o modelo de trabalho da empresa não pode ser considerado como relação de emprego, nos moldes da Consolidação das Leis do Trabalho (CLT). Amaro ponderou que as mudanças tecnológicas também refletiram no mercado de trabalho.

“Aqueles conceitos clássicos da relação de emprego não se aplicam a essas novas formas de trabalho humano. Essas formas não cabem nos limitadíssimos marcos e limites da CLT”, afirmou.


5 comentários

  1. The Halifax casino has more than 500 slot machines and over
    two dozen tables. Grey Rock Casino is a state-of-the-art casino resort with over 250
    slots and dozens of high-quality electronic table games.

    You can also enjoy 75+ table games, a dedicated poker
    room open daily, and 100+ electronic gaming terminals in a stadium-style setup.
    You can also jump into 54 table games, with expert dealers for blackjack, roulette,
    baccarat, craps, and pai gow. Players can enjoy over
    40,000 square feet of gaming space including slots, gaming tables, and
    a poker room. The casino section has 700 slot
    machines, and a beautiful 30 table poker room.

    Australia has 12 active casinos dotted all over the country,
    but largely focused around capital cities and major regional
    hubs. In fact, you’re probably much safer in the average casino near you than you are out on a typical city street, in a department store, or even in most major airports!
    We have even included the telephone numbers of the local Australian casinos,
    so you can grab the phone and make a reservation today.
    Never again ask “Where is the best casino near me?
    Keep in mind that the recipient’s email client settings will determine how prominently the email is displayed as high priority. The nearest seaport to Las Vegas is the Port of Los Angeles, located approximately 270 miles to the southwest. These banks offer medallion signature guarantees to help customers with securities transactions and other financial needs that require verification of a signature. However, you can find carpet cleaning products, such as shampoos and machines for rent, at Tesco stores. No, Tesco does not offer carpet cleaning services directly. Experience the thrill of next generation gaming in the Stadium gaming.

    References:
    https://blackcoin.co/big4-casino-holiday-park-comprehensive-overview/

  2. Not only does the loss on Thursday keep the Lions out of the playoffs, it also puts
    Detroit in last place in the NFC North. With the loss to the Vikings on Thursday, the Lions are officially eliminated from playoff contention. The Detroit Lions had a dream regular season in 2024,
    going 15-2 and earning the top seed in the playoffs,
    but the 2025 season hasn’t been as smooth. The Lions were flagged for offensive pass interference on the game’s final play, erasing a touchdown lateraled to quarterback Jared Goff.
    If the Lions can win out and the Green Bay Packers drop their final two games, Detroit can still sneak into
    the playoffs. But a huge tackle by Daniel Thomas and a sack from Aidan Hutchinson on third down boots the Vikings out of field-goal range and Detroit takes back over on offense.

    In February 2006, Microsoft announced that it intended to expand
    its Redmond campus by 1,100,000 square feet (100,000 m2)
    at a cost of $1 billion and said that this would create space for between 7,000
    and 15,000 new employees over the following three years.
    In January 2006, Microsoft announced the purchase of Safeco’s Redmond campus after
    the company had begun consolidating its offices at the Safeco Tower in Seattle’s University District a year earlier.
    The first major expansion of the campus came in 1992, bringing the
    total amount of office space to 1.7 million square feet (160,000 m2) on 260 acres (110 ha) of land.
    The campus was originally leased to Microsoft from the Teachers Insurance and
    Annuity Association, a pension fund manager, until it was bought back in 1992.

    The Broncos have three first-timers among their six selections,
    while 49ers’ Trent Williams and Kyle Juszczyk set positional records.
    Is the loss of Micah Parsons too much for the Packers to overcome?
    Metcalf’s two-game suspension was upheld by the NFL on Tuesday.

    References:
    https://blackcoin.co/velvet-spin-casino-a-comprehensive-review/

  3. Es ist ein Restaurant mit dem Thema Vereinigte
    Staaten, das eine Vielzahl von Steaks, Wein und Bieren aus den gesamten USA anbietet.
    Eines der kultigsten Restaurants in New York-New York, ein irisches Restaurant und Pub,
    das 2003 eröffnet wurde. März 2014 mit einer großen Eröffnungsparty eröffnet,
    die mit Live-Musik auf der Brooklyn-Brücke des Hotels begann und von dem aus
    Brooklyn stammenden DJ Jonny Santos gestaltet wurde.
    Das neue Geschäft würde mit der nahe gelegenen M&M’s World am Showcase Plaza konkurrieren, die fast 20 Jahre vor der Ankündigung eröffnet wurde.

    Besonders hervorzuheben ist der große Pokerbereich mit 10 Tischen, der tägliche Turniere und verschiedene Pokerspiele anbietet.
    Das Casino, eine der Hauptattraktionen des Hotels, erstreckt sich über beeindruckende 7.804 Quadratmeter und bietet eine vielfältige Auswahl an Spielmöglichkeiten. Der Big
    Apple Coaster, der um das Hotel herumführt, bietet jedes
    Mal aufs Neue Nervenkitzel und fasziniert durch
    seine spektakuläre Fahrt entlang der Skyline. Das New York-New York Hotel Las Vegas bietet nicht nur eine beeindruckende Außenfassade, sondern auch
    ein faszinierendes Innendesign, das die berühmten Stadtteile New Yorks wie den Times Square und
    Central Park nachbildet.
    Der Hauptcasino-Bereich zum Beispiel ist nach dem Times Square benannt, während die Restaurants nach
    dem Vorbild von Greenwich Village gestaltet sind.

    References:
    https://online-spielhallen.de/umfassender-ratgeber-zu-princess-casino-freispielen-alles-was-sie-wissen-mussen/

Deixe um comentário

O seu endereço de e-mail não será publicado. Campos obrigatórios são marcados com *